Yankees Trade Target: Starling Marte

It’s that time of the year again. Trade season is about to heat up across MLB over the next month and change. This year, the trade deadline is 4pm eastern on July 30. As we approach that date, we’ll profile a number of players the Yankees should have their crosshairs on in discussions with other ballclubs. Today’s profile: Marlins’ center fielder Starling Marte.

Simply put, the Yankees need to add a center fielder. Aaron Hicks is out for the season and 37 year-old Brett Gardner simply isn’t a viable option. He’s been better of late, but it’s too much to ask of him to play there every day. Estevan Florial isn’t ready. And running out Aaron Judge in center isn’t ideal, either. So with the Marlins out of contention (29-39) and Marte in the final year of his contract, this sure looks like a match made in heaven.

Background & Performance

Marte, 32 years-old, hails from the Dominican Republic and is in his 10th season in the major leagues. He’s carved out a pretty good big league career in spite of signing with the Pirates for just $85,000 as an international amateur free agent back in 2007.

The righty/righty center fielder debuted for Pittsburgh in 2012 and remained there through 2019 before an offseason trade sent him to Arizona. While in the Steel City, Marte batted .287/.341/.452 (116 wRC+), stole 239 bases, and accumulated 24.0 fWAR in 953 games. However, his numbers were a tad better prior to serving an 80-game suspension in 2017 under the league’s performance enhancing drug policy. Not markedly better, though:

  • 2012 – 2016: .289/.345/.447, 120 wRC+
  • 2017 – 2019: .284/.334/.458, 109 wRC+

He really only exhibited a downturn in that 2017 season (91 wRC+), but otherwise, Marte was remarkably consistent in Pittsburgh before a trade to the Diamondbacks in January 2020.

The trade was far from the biggest upheaval in Marte’s life last year, though. He tragically lost his wife to a heart attack while waiting for surgery on a broken ankle that May. Just horrible. I don’t know how he went on the play last season, but he did. Perhaps the delayed start to the season made it a bit easier for him to take the time he needed away from the field with his family (he has three kids).

Marte got off to a hot start once the season began in 2020. He hit .311/.384/.443 (123 wRC+) before Arizona sent him to the upstart Marlins. Marte struggled post-trade (.245/.286/.415, 92 wRC+), but has rebounded this year around a rib fracture. To date, Marte owns a .331/.429/.534 (170 wRC+) batting line, has five homers, and has swiped 8 bags.

Defensively, Marte didn’t become a full-time center fielder until 2018 (the first year without Andrew McCutchen in Pittsburgh). He primarily played left, though he did spend some time in center before. Marte grades out very well in center field per Statcast, at +17 outs above average since 2018. He’s at +3 this season.

Injury History

As mentioned, Marte spent time on the injured list this season with a rib fracture. He was absent after playing on April 18th until returning on May 28th.

Marte’s injury history isn’t too bad otherwise. He dealt with a sprained wrist and and abdomen contusion in 2019, missing 29 days combined. In 2018, he spent the minimum 10 days on the injured list with an oblique strain. His only other injured list stints ocurred in 2016 (back tightness) and 2013 (finger).


Club options have lengthened Marte’s original six-year, $31 million extension with the Pirates to eight years and $53 million, with this year being the last of the deal. The Marlins picked up his $12.5 million club option for the 2021 campaign, and based on CBA rules, that’s also his luxury tax figure for the year. Obviously, the luxury tax observant Yankees will take that into account in any potential deal.

What would a trade look like?

Marte has more than half of the $12.5 million still coming to him, and with the Yankees having only a couple million in wiggle room under the first tax threshold (per Cot’s), the Bombers would undoubtedly ask for Miami to eat most, if not all, of his salary. Pretty incredible: the financial powerhouse New York Yankees asking the lowly Miami Marlins to take on money. Sigh.

As such, the Yankees will need to send better prospects down south if they expect the Marlins to pay down Marte’s deal. Just like they did with Texas and Rougned Odor. Now, let’s talk trade comps.

I’ll start with last year’s deal for Marte, which sorta was a rental, only because Miami could have bought him out for $1 million last winter. Here’s what Miami sent to Arizona:

  • Caleb Smith through 2023
  • Humberto Mejía through at least 2026
  • Prospect Julio Frias

Smith misses a lot of bats, but has had middling success. Mejía was on the back-end of the Marlins’ top-30 prospect list last season and is currently in Triple-A. Frias, then 22, spent 2019 in short-season A-ball and hadn’t been on any prospect lists. Not a great return!

Let’s also look to another recent notable rental: the deal that sent Nick Castellanos from Detroit to the Cubs in 2019 for right-handed pitching prospects Paul Richan and Alex Lange. Richan is a command-over-stuff righty who’s not a top prospect. Lange was the Cubs’ first-round pick in 2017, but had seen his stock fall and moved to a relief role. Another meh return.

The problem here, again, is that a Yankees trade for Marte probably won’t look remotely like these two. Not if they’re going to ask Miami to kick in money to cover what’s left on Marte’s deal. Ugh. Anyway, let me put my proposal out there. But first, an evergreen reminder:

Here goes nothing: Yoendrys Gomez, Anthony Seigler, and Beck Way for Marte and cash. Do we have a deal, Baseball Trade Values?

Obviously, Marte would be a great fit and fill a glaring need. Not just because the Yankees have an opening in center field, but also because the Yankees sorely need an injection of life into the offense. Marte offers both without a long-term commitment.


DoTF: Medina and Gil make their debuts at new levels


Game 68: A Sweep In Buffalo


  1. Wire Fan

    Kind of sad that a big market team will have to add in prospect value to help shave salary/LT. Penny wise, pound foolish.

    A 50% tax sounds like a massive penalty but if they end up 4-6mil over the threshold it is a 2-3mil tax bill – is that really worth trading extra prospects away for?

  2. dasit

    i guess there’s a chance that 2 of the red sox astros rays a’s indians collapse and the yankees snag a wild card, but outside of that unlikely scenario they’ll need to pass the luxury tax and add some legit offense. hope cashman is making that case to hal right now. the org had been building to 2020 as the ultimate GFIN year, but covid blew up the program. they can either say “oh well” or keep pushing. their decision is likely informed by severino’s status. if he’s done for the year there’s little chance they’ll buy big

  3. DZB

    Speaking of CF, I still keep hearing comments from NYY fans complaining that they need a CF but traded Tauchman. He has a positive bWAR in SF, but is hitting .175 with a .570 OPS (above, but very close to his NY number). At 30 years old, he is what he is, and that is guy who is barely above replacement level.

  4. MBN


    Actually, Mullins is the guy I would rather have instead of Marte. I doubt the O’s would even consider trading him to the Yankees, unless the return is huge. Like starting with Devi and Florial.

    And the O’s aren’t eating any money – not with that owner..

  5. Dani

    If they are buying (big if, if you ask me) I’d also want them to look at the Royals’ Benintendi and Merrifield and the O’s Mullins. Getting another starter would be necessary too imo.

    And let’s be real: if they’re buyers they’ll have to push in their chips, get over the luxury tax and do several trades to make it worth it. Their winning window is closing fast and hey, they might already be past it. 1-2 trades probably isn’t even enough to make the wildcard.

    But let’s get to the deadline first, lots of stuff can and will happen till then. The Yanks should be very busy at the deadline one way or the other though.

  6. Cary

    I don’t see Sterling Marte, a right handed hitter, as being much of a difference maker for the Yankees, who basically have to catch the very consistent Houston Astros in order to squeeze into the playoffs as the final Wild Card team. Houston is 11 games over .500 with a differential of +94. Marte isn’t going to close that gap, the Yankees have too many other glaring issues, in fact he makes the Yankees even more one dimensional than they already are.

  7. DZB

    “just like they did with Texas and Rougned Odor. ”

    This is not really true, is it? Odor had been DFA’d and so Texas was going to have to eat his salary once he cleared waivers and was released. No team was going to claim him on waivers thanks to his salary, so Texas had to eat his salary as a condition of any trade going through (since teams could otherwise wait to sign him after he cleared waivers). It is crazy that they sent real talent to Texas under those conditions, given how horrendous a player Odor is. So I imagine him being free played into that, which sort of supports the point being made here I suppose

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén