The Yankees are beginning to resemble the 2018 Red Sox

Embed from Getty Images

After his team allowed 29 runs to the Yankees in London, Alex Cora told reporters the truth: Boston hasn’t measured up to New York this season.

“Right now, they’re a lot better than us, so we need to get better. We know we can be better. We know we have a great team. But we need to stop talking about it, and we need to do it. It’s 11.5. There’s no hiding. We know where we’re at.”

Funny enough, that resembled quotes from Aaron Boone a year ago when the Yankees were dealt a four-game sweep at Fenway Park in August.

“From the division standpoint, we’re going to have to play a pretty lights-out brand of baseball,” Boone said just before the finale.

“This is a test we’re going through right now, there’s no question. We’re experiencing some adversity with being dinged up a little bit roster-wise, but we’ll also come out on the other side a lot tougher for this.”

Those quotes, 11 months apart, speak to the rise of two juggernauts in the American League East, the 2018 Red Sox and the 2019 Yankees. Both teams had or have exhausting talent on offense that makes up for the papered-over holes in their pitching staff. To play at a 100+ win pace, you don’t need to have perfect pitching if you simply outscore opponents consistently.

In some ways, the Rays are actually the 2018 Yankees equivalent with Boston sitting 11 games off this year’s AL East pace. Tampa Bay has a lot to like — Ace-caliber starting pitching, the makings of a good bullpen, controllable young hitters — but the pieces haven’t come together in full force for more than a few weeks at a time.

Even Tampa is having trouble hanging with the Yankees, going 2-8 thus far in head-to-head contests. That’s closer to the 2-10 mark against New York of this year’s Orioles than anyone in the Rays organization would like. The Tampa Bay Times ran a column Thursday that posited “the Rays are closer to Montreal than they are to the Yankees.” Funny, but also reality.

These Yankees just exhaust any and all pitchers. They blast home runs, sure, but they do much more than that. Get ahead of a Bomber hitter 0-2 and they’ll force you to throw eight more pitches to get them out, if you can even get them out. Tie the game off their best relievers and they’ll just build a lead their worst reliever can’t give up. At least on offense, this has the makings of a special team …

… Except when they run into Justin Verlander.

That was ostensibly the issue for the 2018 Red Sox as well. It seems farfetched now, but after Game 1 of the 2018 ALCS, Boston looked like a 108-win appetizer for the Astros’ second consecutive title. Houston has run out one of the best offenses of all-time in three straight seasons and has the ace pitching to make it stand up, even after losing Charlie Morton to the Rays.

So the 2018 Red Sox aren’t the standard to chase, even though they were eventually World Series winners. They weren’t guaranteed that title at least until they finished off Houston. The Yankees have to measure themselves against potential 2019 foes, namely the Twins, Astros and Dodgers (primarily the latter two). And sure, the Rays and Red Sox, should either emerge as a division/division series competitor in coming weeks.

Around this time last year, the Red Sox saw themselves as the division champions. They still had to finish off the Yankees, but they also had the luxury of looking ahead to the postseason, where the Yankees could reemerge while Houston loomed. Dave Dombrowski looked for relief help but strengthened the rotation instead when Zack Britton went to New York, adding Nathan Eovaldi (and Steve Pearce on offense).

Brian Cashman may find himself in a funhouse mirror version of Boston’s 2018 trade deadline. The Yankees could really use a starter for the postseason — they can get by just fine in the regular season — but the market is thin, particularly with Marcus Stroman dealing with a pectoral injury. He may instead have to bolster an already fortified bullpen after already providing supplementary help to the lineup with Edwin Encarnacion.

If you’re looking in the American League for an equivalent to the Boston champions from last season, the Yankees are it. But that doesn’t guarantee a title. The Bombers have a similarly tough road ahead and reinforcements to make. Still, it’s nice to not be looking up in the division for once.


Mailbag: Injuries, Replacing Romine, IFA vs. Draft, Frazier Service Time


Game 86: Yankees get first look at McKay


  1. Dan A.

    He’s a young guy, so I’m not gonna make too big a deal of it, but I think Frazier needs to raise his maturity level a bit. It’s true the media is a bit too harsh on him, but I still think it’s fair to critique his maturity.

    • Joe

      Did Frazier blast “New York, New York” in Fenway Park after winning one game in a five game series? That seems more immature to me than anything Clint has ever actually or allegedly done.

  2. dasit

    doubt we see severino until 2020

    it’s unfortunate that florial has regressed so badly he would have made a great centerpiece for a bumgarner trade

    my guess is they upgrade the bullpen and hope the starters can go five innings in the post season

  3. Your a Looser Trader FotD

    I wouldn’t sleep on the Twins

    • RetroRob

      Fans take the Twins for granted because of the success the Yankees have had against them, but those are prior teams. They are stronger this season.

  4. CountryClub

    Over the past 2 1/2 seasons, the Yanks, Sox, Astros and Dodgers have clearly been the 4 best teams. Two won a ring, the other one went to the WS twice. It’s time for the Yanks to seal the deal.

    • RetroRob

      The Yankees were a tick behind those other teams developmentally, one of the four best, but not the best. That may no longer be the case.It would be great to add an ace-level pitcher, but the odds of that are slim. There are none available. (Not buying 2019 MadBum as an ace). The Red Sox, though, showed last year you don’t need an ace to win it. Sale was hardly an the latter part of 2018 and in the postseason (or this year, for that fact).

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén