The Longest Tenured Yank Bounces Back, Again [2021 Season Review]

Embed from Getty Images

At this point, you know how you feel about Brett Gardner. You either believe the 38-year-old outfield staple has a place on the Yanks until he hangs up the cleats or you think it’s embarrassing that the Yanks keep bringing him back on what is ostensibly a title contender. Little will change anyone’s mind on this. I do want to offer a few fun facts about the longest-tenured Yankee, though:

  • Gardner’s 44.3 career bWAR as a Yankee is good for 17th in franchise history. It’s more than Don Mattingly (42.4) and Jorge Posada (42.7), while ranking just behind Robinson Canó (44.4).
  • If his career was spent entirely in Toronto instead of New York, he would be the best position player in Blue Jays history by bWAR, ranking ahead of Jose Bautista (38.3). That is also true in Arizona (Paul Goldschmidt, 39.9) and Miami (Giancarlo Stanton, 35.7). He’d even be close for the crosstown Mets (David Wright, 49.2).
  • With 1,688 games played in pinstripes, just 12 other people in history have played more games for the Yankees. (With one more season under his belt, he will be in the top 10 in this category.)
  • Gardner has 1,470 hits as a Yankee. Just 21 individuals have more in pinstripes.

That is just some context about Gardner, who is a much bigger part of Yankee history than you likely thought. Anyway, Gardy put up a .222/.327/.362 (93 wRC+) line in 140 games for New York as he was once again thrust into regular playing time. He often looked rough, particularly during the first half, but he rebounded in a serious way after the All-Star Break.

This is me, watching Gardner play during August and September:

Let’s break down his performance, shall we?

A Tale of Two Halves

As I noted back in our 2019 Gardner review, the lefty once had a deserved reputation for falling off in the second half of seasons. Here is a chart lifted from that analysis for some context:

First HalfSecond Half
Career.271/.353/.421 (108 tOPS+).244/.328/.374 (89 tOPS+)

There’s no mistaking it. He’s been better in first halves historically, to the point where his second half declines would lead to a spirited offseason discussion regarding his future. Lately, though, he has really reversed that trend. In fact, Gardner has become a much better player in the second half than the first ever since.

While that was most dramatic in 2019, it was true once again in 2021. (It was last year, too, but there wasn’t a traditional second half so we can leave that to the side for now.) In fact, Gardner looked positively cooked in the first half of 2021, hitting just .194/.310/.304 (75 wRC+) overall. It really did look like age had finally caught up with our man.

Then, though, things changed a bit. Gardner hit .250/.344/.418 (111 wRC+) in the second half. Unfortunately, that basically made him one of the most potent players in the Yankees’ lackluster offense – but that doesn’t really matter. What matters is that Gardner looked really, really good again.

And, in fact, even this overall split is a bit deceptive. Gardner didn’t really start cooking until August 1, after which point he hit .261/.351/.441 (119 wRC+) with a 11.9% walk rate and a 18.9% strikeout rate. Six of his 10 home runs came in August and September, as did 15 of his 30 extra-base hits overall. Here’s are illustrative graphs:

He started hitting the ball harder and with more consistency, and the results followed. That’s about all there is to it. Why that happened is beyond me, and ultimately doesn’t matter. He’s a good player who rebounded – so much for the end of Brett Gardner, huh?

Fastballs, Fastballs, Fastballs

It wasn’t all rosy for Gardner, though. Far from it. Two good months do not a season make, nor do they entirely compensate for declining skills at the plate. There is one specific concern that arose in 2021: Gardner basically stopped hitting offspeed offerings entirely.

From 2017-20, Gardner hit a .254/.299/.397 against such pitches, which was better than the league average .234/.282/.387. Pitchers threw them at him about just over 12% of the time during that stretch. Then, this year, he fell off dramatically, hitting just .146/.180/.250 against offspeed pitches. League average, by contrast, was .231/.280/.379. That is a very significant decline!

It is also somewhat worrying, given two things. First, Gardner has never really hit breaking balls (.241 career wOBA; .265 league average), and that didn’t change in 2021 – in fact, it got a bit worse, as his wOBA against breaking balls to .220. While he’s always hit fastballs, and continued to do so in 2021, that leaves just Gardy with two vulnerabilities going into next season, not one. Second, he actually saw fewer offspeed pitches than normal:

Not a huge drop off, actually, but a significant one given that Gardy was mostly successful against fastballs. It may even have contributed to his second half bounce back. Look at the pitch percentage by month in 2021:

As we look toward 2022, this is an area of concern. If I were developing a game plan against Gardner, I would focus on hammering him with breaking balls and offspeed stuff most of the time. That approach would likely work, and it would minimize his ability to do damage against fastballs, against which he hit .264/.389/.432 in 2021.

Speed and Patience are Skills That Stay

Still, where there’s regression with Brett Gardner, there’s consistency. He has long been one of the speediest Yankee players. That was still true in 2021, even in his age-38 season. His sprint speed, per Statcast, was 28.6 feet per second in 2021 – just a hair slower than it was in 2015, the first year Statcast tracked such data. While there were faster Yankees in 2021 – remember Tim Locastro? – Gardy was, once again, the quickest Yankee regular last season. (His defense, by contrast, was just middling.)

At the same time, sprint speed is not a super reliable proxy for speed – it measures only top speed, which is misleading. How fast one can run is not the only factor in measuring speed. Acceleration, duration, and consistency are also key factors. By another, more effective measure, Gardner has indeed slowed down a bit. It takes him, on average, 4.15 seconds to reach first base from home these days. That’s slower than 4.09 in 2015, though it was tied with Tyler Wade for fastest on the Yankees.

Still, some age-related decline with speed is to be expected for a player with a long career like Gardner. What’s more remarkable is that he’s barely slowed down at all: he’s still in the 87th percentile across the league. Speed plays, and it’s a valuable skill for him to have.

Similarly, Gardner has always been an extremely patient hitter at the plate – the epitome of working a pitcher. That also did not change in 2021, as he saw 4.54 pitches per plate appearance. Gardy was just 41 at-bats short of qualifying last year but, if he had, that rate would have lead the league by a significant margin. You could argue that Gardner should swing more, since he does take a lot of belt-high fastballs:

But I’m fine with it. This is who Brett Gardner is, and that’s fine. In fact, it’s a skill in-and-of-itself – and it’s one that’s not likely to go away even in the swan song days of his career. Brett Gardner, so long as he remains in pinstripes, will remain the speedy, patient left-handed bat we all remember.

What’s Next

Who knows? Gardner’s contract has a split option next year, and he could opt-in to join the Yankees. If he does, his salary would be $2.3 million for 2022. That’s just under his $2.85 million 2021 deal (he had a $1 million signing bonus, remember), and probably fair market deal. If Gardy declines, there is no chance the Yankees pick up his $7.15 million club option – they’d simply buy him out for $1.15 million.

Anyway, this is somewhat complicated, but it doesn’t need to be. Gardy is on-the-record as saying he wants to return to New York, and I think $2.3 million is fair market rate for a reliable, if declining, backup outfield option with durable skills. I expect Gardner to utilize his option for 2022, return to pinstripes, and look to retire after a trip down the Canyon of Heroes.


Mailbag: DJ LeMahieu’s role, Aaron Boone’s culpability, Ketel Marte at shortstop


Thoughts on clubhouse leaks and offseason needs


  1. Wire Fan

    I wouldn’t mind Gardy as a backup OF, if he was indeed a backup OF.

    With Hicks starting in CF, Gardner will almost certainly have long stretches where he is an everyday CF. And while Judge remained mostly healthy last year, he also has the same risk.

    The Yankee 4th OF needs to be close to an every day OF’r. Not necessarily a star, but someone you would be OK playing every day for a month or two at a time. if the Yankee OF was less of a health risk, he would be fine.

  2. Mike

    Keep Gardy , just raise the Stella beers up to an even $20.00

  3. chip56

    Gardner’s gotta go.

    He stopped hitting offspeed stuff because he was cheating to catch up to fastballs.
    Beyond that he’s a fool for not being able to read the room with his mocking of Gerrit Cole and the Spidertack situation. Cole, rightly or wrongly, had been made the face of this “issue” and instead of understanding that this was probably a hornet’s nest best left unkicked, Brett went ahead and picked at the scab anyway.

    At this point, the guy is a solid defensive outfielder with a limited bat. You could get 90% of what he gives you at a fraction of the cost with a Gregg Allen-type.

    Tell him his time is done, wish him well, and invite him back to play with the rest of the old timers.

  4. Meh, at this point I’m fine with giving Gardy one year contracts for baby money til he wants to call it a career. He’s a serviceable depth option but the problem is he has been pressed into everyday roles. Gardy should let the Yankees sign who they need to make the team better this offseason and then sign on for whatever they wanna give him

  5. Anthony Rizzeddardo

    Gardy’s a True Yankee, Bobby, and that’s all that really matters. If he wants to come back they should bring him back. Gardy had a really good 2nd half and can still play, though he’s not an everyday player. But his greatest quality is probably team jokester. Unfortunately, this wokeism epidemic has even penetrated baseball clubhouses. It was recently reported that Gardy tried to lighten the mood after Gerrit Cole’s spider tack revelation and make a joke of it to loosen up the clubhouse. But Cole couldn’t take a joke and told Gardy to stop it or he’d tell Boone. It’s like really? Cole is supposed to be our tough as nails “ace” with ice water in his veins and he can’t even take a joke? And this is in direct contrast to Braves ace Charlie Morton, who has earned the ace label, pitching on a broken leg for an inning last night to help his club win a World Series. This is exactly why the Braves are in the World Series and the Yankees have gone backwards the last few years. Weak, not tough, woke, lazy, however you want to describe it and it starts at the top with Boone and filters down to the rest of the club. Gardy is a dying breed of old school toughness that is desperately needed around here and the Yankees should be begging him to return.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén