An Obligatory Preseason Lineup Post

As obligatory as a post about the lineup, so is the following statement. Overall, lineup construction doesn’t mean a whole lot unless you really screw it up. We may not be Aaron Boone’s biggest fans here, but we know he’s not going to hit Isiah Kiner-Falefa leadoff and Aaron Judge ninth. Still, it’s a fun thing to muse about and when there isn’t any real action to dissect yet, it’s a good thought exercise.

This one in particular was brought on by the lineup the Yankees put out in their Spring Training matchup with the Blue Jays yesterday:

For one reason or another, one I couldn’t entirely place and really still can’t, I liked the top-6 of that lineup, not just the players, but the way they were ordered. I’d probably flip DJ LeMahieu and Aaron Hicks, however, and the addition of Anthony Rizzo would necessitate those previous two moving down. Putting Rizzo in there means it’s the full strength lineup. Here’s how I’d order them.

  1. Aaron Judge, RF
  2. Josh Donaldson, 3B
  3. Joey Gallo, LF
  4. Giancarlo Stanton, DH
  5. Anthony Rizzo, 1B
  6. Aaron Hicks, CF
  7. DJ LeMahieu, 2B
  8. Isiah Kiner-Falefa, SS

If you want to put Rizzo first like the Yankees did at times last year and bump everyone else down a spot, sure, why not? But I really like the idea of Judge and Donaldson–two power and 0n-base guys–in front of Gallo and Stanton. Stanton, Rizzo, and Hicks can all work walks reasonably well, too, and could/should provide some men-on-base opportunities for LeMahieu and the rest of the bottom of the order.

Looking at the lineup laid out this way made me feel a bit better about the season’s outlook. There’s still a need for bouncebacks–Gallo, Hicks, LeMahieu, even Rizzo to an extent–but the top four is just as good as most any team’s top four which could help balance out some of the, uh, not so great anticipated production from shortstop and catcher.

The Yankees are–or should be–good enough that the lineup won’t matter too much. However, given the potential question marks and potential dead spots in the order, it does behoove Boone and company to make the lineup as optimized and organized as possible.


2022 Storylines: The catching situation


Mailbag: Aaron Judge extension, Hicks in center, Gardner rumors


  1. Wire Fan

    No way judge should bat leadoff. His 2nd AB would mean IFK and catcher hitting in front of him… which is not good for the teams best hitter. At a minimum I’d swap judge and Donaldson

    Which again makes Cashman punting offense at the 8, 9 positions… curious at best.

  2. Tom Mulhearn

    Maybe I’m Old School….but I don’t like a .199 Hitter hitting 3rd. How about flipping Rizzo and Gallo.

  3. Will

    This lineup guarantees that Judge will have no one on base for 20-25 percent of his plate appearances and, with the two dead bats at the end of the lineup, for the overwhelming majority of the rest. If the Yankees insist on batting Judge and Donaldson first and second, they should have Higgy, Benny Biceps, and I’zza Kinda-Falafel bat 6th and 7th, so the the power guys will occasionally have some one to drive in. To the best of my knowledge, Earl Weaver never said anything about pitching, defense, and ONE run homers.

  4. The Original Drew

    It sucks that Gleyber isn’t capable of playing SS or else the lineup is even better. Hell you could put Kiner back at Catcher.

    These things usually have a way or working themselves out but putting DJ or Torres on the bench on a regaular basis is just a book look for an offense that struggled as much as it did last year.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén