A Deeper Look at Gary Sánchez’s Strikeouts

Not going anywhere

Dispensing with pleasantries before we even get to one, let’s just say that Gary Sánchez is not having a strong start to the 2020 season. In eight games, he has just two hits and one walk. In his 27 plate appearances, he has struck out 14 times. To quote a former Yankee manager and recent Yankee opponent, it’s not what you want. Let’s take a look at the how and the why for this ugliness and try to draw some conclusions.

When a player is striking out a lot more than normal, the first thing to consider might be if he’s swinging any more or less in general. That doesn’t seem to be the case as he’s about where he was last year, though with a slight downturn against offspeed pitching.

To spare you some more graphs, I’ll skip ahead to what I found most interesting in Sánchez’s swing profile this season. First, here’s his in-zone swing percentages.

Pretty normal, huh? And it seems to match with his overall swing percentages: about the same as always, but slightly less on offspeed. Now, here’s his in-zone swing-and-miss percentages.

Oh, boy. While the breaking and offspeed lines aren’t too alarming, that fastball one is…yikes. Whiffing on that many fastballs in the zone is not going to be a winning strategy for any hitter, even one as talented as Gary.

His out-of-zone numbers tell a similar story: a relatively normal distribution of pitches and a higher rate of whiffs:

We can see increases in chase/whiff percentages on both fastballs and breaking pitches. It’s never good when you expand the zone and miss those pitches you’re expanding on.

Overall, his strikeout percentages look like this:

Two of those lines are heading in a Not Great direction, aren’t they?

To drive the point home about misses even more, let’s look at his zone profile from Brooks:

Middle and up in the zone, he’s whiffing a lot. Up out of the zone, he’s wiffing a lot; those two areas–broad as they are–correlate with the fastball whiff percentages from the Statcast graphs. The middle and lower right portions of the zone profile correlate with the breaking whiff percentages from the Statcast data.

Almost nothing on the offensive side has looked good for Gary in 2020. But there are silver linings. It’s early in the season (funny to say in August) so there’s a lot of variance and extremity to these numbers. That alone means they’re going to come back down. Additionally, according to Statcast, the little contact he’s making has been pretty quality. He ranks in the 83rd percentile for exit velocity and in the 6oth for hard hit percentage. Once Gary starts making more consistent contact, things should level out for him. And when that happens, he can carry an offense.


An appreciation of Tommy Kahnle


Game 10: Home in Philly


  1. You don’t need charts and graphs to see that Sanchez hasn’t been able to hit a fastball at all and looks pathetic on breaking pitches. Outside of the one ground ball single to right field I haven’t even seen him hit a ball hard, even foul.

    Maybe he turns it around, maybe he doesn’t (he needs to start making consistent contact at some point in time or the Yankees need a new catcher), but he’s making his awful 2018 season look good by comparison

  2. Gary always seems to be swinging for the fences. He should get back to basics and just focus on driving the ball back up the middle. That works for a lot of hitters.

  3. The Original Drew

    Gary Sanchez’s bat is very low (along with Gerrit Cole not dominating and Gleyber’s struggles) of things that concern me right now for the Yankees.

    They will correct itself. Just give it a little time.

  4. Gerreddardit Cole

    I just don’t think he cares, Matt. Judge and Gary both came up and struck out a lot. Judge dedicated himself to fixing the issue and is now the greatest player in the game. Gary has gone the opposite direction. Girardi and Tony Pena tried to get through to him. They said he had lost a lot of weight this offseason but to me he still looks fat. Look at what Stanton and Voit did to transform their bodies. Why can’t the guy slim down and work on his hitting? Pitchers seem to like him but all he is now is an ordinary .200 hitting catcher. At this point I’d start giving Higgy more playing time. At least he puts the bat on the ball. Can’t be any worse. When Gary does play Boone needs to move him down in the order to 8th or 9th. He should certainly hit behind red hot Gio.

  5. Speculating that there is something physically wrong here with Gary. His at bats look putrid. Maybe vision, maybe muscular, but something is wrong

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén